10 Best Cookie Jars 2025 in the United States

The Lenox Holiday Ornament Cookie Jar is made of porcelain, giving it a classic and durable feel, perfect for holiday-themed kitchen decor with its red and green colors. It offers a good capacity of 4.2 liters, which should hold a fair amount of cookies without being too bulky on your countertop. The jar measures about 10.9 by 10 by 8.75 inches, making it a medium-sized option suitable for most kitchens.

It has a snap closure, which helps keep cookies fresh but may not provide an airtight seal like some silicone or rubber seals do, so cookies might stay fresh for a shorter time. Regarding cleaning, this jar requires hand washing, as it is not dishwasher safe, which might be a bit inconvenient if you prefer easy cleanup. The design is festive and charming, ideal for those who want a decorative piece that doubles as storage during the holidays. While it is durable, it is not microwaveable, so it’s strictly for storage rather than heating.

This cookie jar is a suitable choice for anyone looking for a decorative, mid-sized holiday-themed jar with solid build quality. However, if you want something with an airtight seal or dishwasher safe convenience, you might want to consider other options.

The Lenox 895260 Bayberry Cookie Jar is a charming porcelain jar designed with festive red and green colors, making it a great choice for holiday settings or seasonal hosting. Its size is moderate, standing about 8.25 inches tall and 6.75 inches in diameter, with a 64-ounce (roughly 4-pound) capacity—large enough to hold a good amount of cookies without taking up too much counter space. The jar features a wooden lid that provides an airtight seal, which helps keep cookies fresh, although the seal depends on the lid fitting well rather than a rubber gasket.

One downside is that this cookie jar is not dishwasher or microwave safe and requires hand washing, which might be inconvenient if you prefer easy cleaning. However, the porcelain material gives it a sturdy and elegant feel, suitable for display as well as storage. It’s also fairly lightweight at about 1 pound, making it easy to move around or store away after the holidays.

The design is festive and classic, perfect for Christmas or winter-themed décor, which might not suit everyday use or other seasons. It comes with Lenox’s Replacement Promise, adding some confidence in durability. This cookie jar is well suited for holiday decorating and gifting but requires a bit more care in cleaning and is best used seasonally.

The Anchor Hocking Montana 1.5 Gallon Glass Jar is a solid choice for anyone looking to store cookies and other dry goods. Made from durable glass, it resists stains and odors and doesn’t leach chemicals, making it a safe option for food storage. The 1.5-gallon capacity is generous, allowing for ample storage space, and the wide mouth design makes it easy to scoop contents out without spilling. The black metal lid, which features a silicone gasket, provides a tight seal to keep contents fresh.

The jar may be a bit bulky for smaller kitchens due to its dimensions (8.62 inches wide and 10.2 inches high) and weight (5 pounds). The design is simple and functional, with a clear glass body that allows you to see the contents easily and a sturdy, substantial feel that ensures it won’t tip over easily. Cleaning is a breeze as the jar is dishwasher safe, adding to its convenience. On the downside, the metal lid might need occasional hand washing to prevent wear over time.

The product is made in the USA, adding to its appeal for those who prefer domestically produced goods. With no assembly required, it seems to be a well-received product among users.