10 Best Hard Shell Car Top Carriers 2025 in the United States

The SportRack Vista XL Rear Opening Cargo Box offers substantial storage with an 18 cubic foot capacity, making it ideal for those needing extra space for road trips or family vacations. Its dimensions (63 x 38 x 19 inches) provide ample room for various items. Despite its large size, the cargo box is relatively lightweight at 28 pounds, which aids in easier handling and installation. The box is made from durable, UV-resistant ABS plastic, ensuring longevity and protection against the elements. The rear-opening design is a practical feature as it allows access away from traffic, enhancing safety during use. The tool-free mounting system simplifies installation and removal, making it accessible even for those who are not technically inclined.

It is compatible with various rack systems including SportRack, square bars, round bars, and most factory racks, although users should check the fit guide to ensure compatibility with their vehicle. Security is well-addressed with an included key and lock system, securing both the contents and the box itself to the roof rack. However, the aerodynamics could be affected due to its size and shape, potentially impacting fuel efficiency. The maximum weight capacity of 100 pounds should suffice for most needs but may be limiting for heavier loads. This cargo box is a strong contender for anyone looking for a robust and spacious storage solution that is easy to install and provides good security, though those highly concerned with fuel efficiency might need to weigh the pros and cons.

The Thule 614 Pulse Rack is a hard-shell car top carrier that offers 14 cubic feet of additional storage space, making it ideal for family road trips or outdoor adventures. Its rugged design, made from durable plastic, ensures that your belongings stay protected from the elements. The dimensions (67 x 35 x 16 inches) provide ample room and it can hold up to 110 lbs of gear, including up to 5 snowboards with a maximum length of 155 cm.

The carrier weighs 34 lbs, which is relatively light for its category, making it easier to handle during installation and removal. The FastGrip quick-mount system is a standout feature, allowing for fast and secure mounting in minutes. Additionally, the passenger-side opening simplifies loading and unloading, especially in tight spaces. The central locking system enhances security, and the Thule Comfort Key ensures that the box is properly secured by only allowing the key to be removed when all locking points are fastened.

However, there are a few drawbacks to consider. The aerodynamic design could be more refined, as the box's height off the crossbar (16 inches) may impact vehicle fuel efficiency. Also, while the box is water-resistant, it may not be completely waterproof in heavy rain conditions. Despite these minor issues, the Thule 614 Pulse Rack remains a reliable option for those needing extra cargo space on their vehicles.

The Yakima SkyBox NX Large is a sturdy hard-shell cargo carrier offering 16 cubic feet of storage, providing enough space to carry gear for up to three campers, including items like snowboards and skis. Its dimensions (75.5" long, 35" wide, and 16" high) and weight (46 pounds) make it a solid option if you have a larger vehicle and need a spacious box without going too heavy. The box is made of durable plastic with a nano-textured finish that gives it a sleek, modern look and helps resist water, keeping your belongings protected from rain. One of the standout features is the dual-sided opening, allowing you to load or unload from either side of your vehicle, which is convenient in tight parking spots or uneven terrain. It also has a full metal handle for easy and secure locking, adding to the security of your cargo.

Installation is straightforward thanks to the included torque-limiting knob, ensuring the box stays firmly mounted on a wide variety of roof crossbars, including Yakima’s own StreamLine bars and common factory or aerodynamic ones. While the aerodynamic design helps reduce drag compared to bulkier carriers, it is not the absolute best in this area, so you might notice some impact on fuel efficiency during long trips. At 46 pounds, it can be somewhat heavy to handle alone when empty, which might be a consideration if you frequently want to remove it. Some users appreciate the flat, unobstructed floor inside, which makes packing easier, but the large size may not fit all vehicles comfortably, so checking the fit with your roof and crossbars is recommended.

Customer ratings average around 4 stars, indicating most users are satisfied, though some may find it bulky or a bit pricey. This carrier is suitable for those who want a durable, spacious, and secure box with easy access on both sides, especially for outdoor trips involving multiple people or bulky gear.